Stories from the Coulee · The Cozy Wabasha Cabin

The Song They Sing on Lake Pepin

By Steven Stark

November 10, 2026

The Mississippi River at Wabasha, looking toward Lake Pepin.

The river at Wabasha, on the way to Lake Pepin. Our water. The wreck wasn't here — but the song is.

When the wind picks up out on Lake Pepin, the whitecaps start standing up.

And somebody always says it.

Oh no. Watch the whitecaps.

And then somebody sings the song.

Fifty-one years ago today, November 10, 1975, the Edmund Fitzgerald went down on Lake Superior. No distress call. Twenty-nine men went down with her, and not one of them was ever found.

Superior is a few hours north of here. But down here on the Mississippi, that wreck is still the yardstick for bad water.

I should tell you, I really thought it was Lake Pepin. For years. Which is totally incorrect — it was Superior. But that's how big that story is around here. Our lake tried to claim it, and so did I.

Maybe that's why I thought it was Pepin. The legend lives on from the Chippewa on down — and it came all the way down to us.

Here's how it happened, the way I remember it told.

The ship's captain was supposedly on his final voyage. The ship was on its final run of the season.

The sailors went out and did know there was weather expected. In those days, there was the expectation that you would make the run. Regularly. Storms or not. It was not the ocean, so the thought was it would be fine.

At some point the wind picked up. And really picked up.

There was actually a boat following her, maybe 10 miles behind.

Word is the waves were suddenly 25 feet tall and the wind gusted up to 70 mph. And poof — all radar lost them.

29 souls would never be found.

Gordon Lightfoot had no connection to that ship. He read about the wreck in Newsweek — a short little article. They even spelled the ship's name wrong. Called her the Edmond.

He thought the story was too short for what happened to those men. So he wrote the song. It came out in 1976 and went to number two in the country.

That's why a wreck on Lake Superior gets sung about on a river lake in Minnesota. The song wouldn't let it stay a news story. It's a memorial that fits in your head, and it comes back out every time the wind stands the water up.

So when it blows on Pepin and the whitecaps start up, somebody starts in. Nobody hums that song. They sing it.

Somebody always sings the song.

The song tells the story. And it makes me a little sad.

— Steven